It took the city of New York four years to get another National League team once the New York Giants and the Brooklyn Dodgers left after the 1957 season. The New York Mets would enter the National League in 1962, made up largely of former New York players like Duke Snider and Gil Hodges. Former Yankee manager Casey Stengel would run the team, a team expected to go nowhere but a team that would at least get National League baseball back in New York…where it belonged.

The original Mets were awful. They started the season stuck in an elevator in a St. Louis hotel. In the first game ever played, they lost 11-4 to the Cardinals with Al Jackson getting the loss, the first of a record 120 losses that season. The Mets finally won their first game of the season after losing nine in a row. At Forbes Field on April 23, 1962, the Mets defeated the Pittsburgh Pirates by a score of 9-1. Jay Hook has the distinction of being the first pitcher in Mets history to record a win. It was the first of only 40 that inaugural season.

The hapless Mets were a laughing stock. But to their fans they were the lovable Mets. On that 1962 team was a player who was a favorite New York son, Gil Hodges, who was one of the Brooklyn Boys of Summer. Gil was winding down as a player and soon would try his hand at managing. Also on that ’62 team was a 17 year old rookie who played in just three games for the Mets that season. His name was Ed Kranepool, a left handed first baseman the Mets hoped would someday be a star. Both Hodges and Kranepool would be the only Mets left from that 1962 club come October 1969.

October 16, 1969, World Series Game 5

Shea Stadium – Jerry Koosman pitched about as dominantly as anyone could against the mighty Orioles in game 2, just four days prior. He gave up just one run in eight and two thirds innings in the first Mets win of the series. On this day, he was faced with the opportunity of becoming the winning pitcher in the potential clinching game of the 1969 World Series.

Koosman would face Dave McNally as he did in game 2. That Sunday afternoon, McNally held the Mets in check most of the game with the Mets ultimately prevailing 2-1. Game 5, like game 2, was predicted to be another pitcher’s duel. For the Mets, their motivation was not to go back to Baltimore. But for the Orioles, it was a must win. Lose and their season would be over. It would be a bitter pill to swallow for Baltimore having won 109 regular season games.

The first two innings were quiet with only a mild threat by the Mets in the first when McNally issued two walks. But in the top of the third, Mark Belanger led off with a single. Koosman then surrendered a home run to Dave McNally, the pitcher of all players. The Orioles had jumped out to a 2-0 lead. Koosman got the next two outs but Frank Robinson followed with a solo shot giving the O’s a 3-0 lead. After the inning, Koosman was quoted in the dugout as saying "Hold them there boys, they are not getting anything else the rest of the game”.

Koosman led off the third and almost hit one out as he doubled off the left field wall. But the regular Mets hitters were unable to get anything going offensively against McNally in the third or any of the middle innings. Meanwhile, Koosman settled in and was true to his word. The Orioles were unable to mount any rally since the third.

Cleon Jones led off the sixth inning. During his at bat, McNally threw a ball low and in that appeared to hit Jones in the foot. As Cleon started for first, Lou DiMuro, the home plate umpire called him back claiming he was not hit by the pitch. As Jones settled back in the box, Mets manager Gil Hodges came out to home plate carrying the ball that bounced into the dugout allegedly off of Jones’ show. For a minute, DiMuro and Hodges talked while looking at the ball. Hodges was apparently pointing at what appeared to be shoe polish. Convinced, DiMuro sent Jones to first. Hodges walked back to the dugout as Weaver came out to argue. The discussion did not last long. Jones was on first and Donn Clendenon came up to bat.

Whether the shoe polish came from Cleon’s shoe or Koosman’s while sitting in the dugout is debatable. But the move paid off as Clendenon launched a bomb into the left field loge section for a two run home run to make it a one run game. The homer was the third for Clendenon, the most ever in a five game series up to that point. After six, the Orioles led 3-2.

Koosman continued to dominate in the seventh retiring the Birds in order. In the bottom half of the inning, light hitting journeyman, Al Weis hit a home run to lead off the inning and tie the game. Al Weis was proving to be one pesky player in the World Series. It was his hit in game 2 that drove in the game winning run. Here was a guy who hit two regular season home runs and now he just hit the biggest of his career. The crowd was going wild. You could feel the momentum building for the Mets who had tied the game at three. 

Koosman retired the Orioles in order again in the eighth. 

Eddie Watt relieved McNally in the bottom half. Cleon Jones led off with a double. Now Mets fans were on their feet. But Clendenon grounded out with Brooks Robinson holding Jones at second. With one out Ron Swoboda came up. Just the day before, Swoboda made the most unlikely of plays in the history of the World Series when his incredible diving catch saved the game for the Mets. Ron came through again, this time with his bat as he doubled down the left field line. Jones scored from second. The Mets had the lead. The stands at Shea were vibrating as fans jumped up and down. Everyone at that ballpark and watching on TV knew the Mets were three outs away from the impossible.

Maybe the wheels were falling off for Baltimore. With two outs, Grote hit a ground ball that was booted by Powell. Grote reached first. But as Watt picked up the ball he fired wildly to home as Swoboda scored. Two errors on the play and the Mets had an insurance run. Heading to the top of the ninth, the Mets held a 5-3 lead.

Mets fans were still standing when the ninth inning began. Koosman had dominated since the third inning when he gave up the two home runs. Frank Robinson led off with a walk. Boog Powell came up as the tying run. But Koosman got Powell to hit a ground ball to Weis who got the force at short with Harrelson covering. Brooks Robinson then hit a fly ball to right field. Swoboda settled under it and now there were two down.

Powell was still on first. 57,397 crazed Mets fans were standing and cheering. The sound at Shea was deafening without a plane in site. Davey Johnson came up to the plate, the Orioles last chance.  When Johnson hit the ball, there was silence for a moment. It looked, at least on TV, that Johnson hit it hard. Koosman did not like the sound it made coming off the bat. But the ball held up perhaps from the October wind blowing in from left.  Jones moved back to the warning track. He turned and held his glove out with his bare hand assisting, caught the ball and knelt down to the ground punctuating one of the greatest seasons in baseball history. The Mets were World Champions.

Record - Mets 4, Orioles 1, in best of seven series.

Epilogue – The New York Mets became the first expansion team to win the World Series. And it only took eight years from their inception.  It was done by building a wealth of talent in their farm system and making keen trades by Johnny Murphy, the Mets GM who took over in 1968. It also took great guidance by their manager Gil Hodges who should be in the Hall of Fame. He was a great teacher and a tremendous leader who instilled confidence in his team that they could achieve, that they had the talent to win.

1969 was perhaps the most amazing season in New York baseball history. Unlike the many mighty Yankee teams, the 1986 Mets, the dominating Giant teams of the early twenties or the Dodgers of Brooklyn in the late forties and fifties who were all expected to win, the ’69 Mets were not. And although I hate when the ’69 Mets are referred to as the Miracle Mets, the miracle was in their unexpected rise to greatness, not what they achieved on the field.

Winning 107 games was not accomplished by miracles. It was done through great pitching, hitting, and defense. Sure, there were moments when you scratched your head. Moments like when the black cat stared into the Cubs dugout, or when both pitchers knocked in the only run of a doubleheader to win both games in Pittsburgh, or when Ron Swoboda hit two home runs to win the game in St. Louis when Steve Carlton set the record for striking out nineteen, or even the shoe polish play in game five.  But those moments would have gone unnoticed if it was not for the spectacular play day in and day out by this group of twenty-five individuals.

For me, the 1969 season will always be the summer of my life. I was thirteen and the Mets taught me a valuable lesson. No matter how the odds are stacked against you, there are always possibilities. Never give up, always strive to get better, and never let anyone convince you that you cannot succeed. And who said baseball is just a game?

Unfortunately, the Mets did not repeat in 1970. They were competitive for most of the season but ended just a few games above .500 in third place six games behind the Pirates. Cincinnati won the National League pennant but lost to the Orioles in the World Series who made amends to their fans for losing to the Mets a year earlier. The Mets returned to the World Series in 1973 to lose in seven games to the Oakland A’s. They would not return again until 1986.

1969 did not start the era of dominance Mets fans had hoped. In fact, sustained success has always been something that has eluded this franchise. The Mets became a powerhouse in the mid to late 80’s but again only appeared in and won just one World Series. Now as we watch the Mets struggle after such a promising season in 2006, we ask when will the Mets climb back to the top again.

A season like 1969 comes perhaps once in a lifetime. But if there is one franchise that seems to have a knack for the unexpected, it’s the Mets. A team that did what it did in ’69, almost won it all in ’73 when they were in last place in mid August, came back to win game six down to their last strike several times in ’86, is due for something special. 

On October 20, 1969, the Mets were ushered down the Canyon of Heros with a ticker tape parade. A couple of weeks later it was announced that in the National League Tom Seaver won the Cy Young award, Gil Hodges was the manager of the year, and Tommie Agee was the comeback player of the year. Mets GM Johnny Murphy was given the Executive of the Year award also.

I hope you enjoyed reading “40 Years Ago Today” this season as much as I have enjoyed writing it. It brought back great memories for me. I hope it did for you too. And if you are too young to have experienced that magical season, I hope it provided you with a sense of what it was like to be a Mets fan back then.

Thanks to retrosheet.org, ultimatemets.com, and to the many authors of books and newspaper articles I have kept over the years. They all helped jar my memory of each day of the 1969 season.