I’m having a hard time understanding why Metropolitan fans have been so angry this season. I get being disappointed, but the anger puzzles me. I don’t get it.
I’m getting a bit frustrated with all the talking heads and their lopsided analysis. Some say fire Omar Minaya while others suggest Jerry Manuel has lost his mind. And others claim it’s all the Wilpon’s fault because they don’t spend enough money. Being disappointed in where we hoped the Mets would be prior to the All Star break and where they actually are is totally understandable. But some of the reaction is just plain bizarre. I’m sure the frustration of the last two seasons has a lot to do with it.
This season, the Mets have been ravaged by injury. The disabled have not been the role players. It’s been the stars of the team. Carlos Delgado, Jose Reyes, now Carlos Beltran have left a gaping hole in the lineup. The tandem of J.J. Puts and Francisco Rodriguez were to have been the best game ending 1-2 punch in the game. But a bone spur in Putz’s elbow had other ideas. Important starters John Maine and Oliver Perez were to have improved and helped make the rotation one of the best in the game. But
Then subs were injured too. Alex Cora and Angel Pagan have taken their turn with injuries. Cora continues to play with a completely torn tendon in his thumb and Pagan may be back soon to fill in for Fernando Martinez who is also suffering from a sore knee. The Mets have basically been a MASH unit all season long.
Whose fault is it? Is it Omar’s fault that players were injured? You think Fred and Jeff Wilpon are happy the team has suffered such colossal injuries considering they sign the checks for the second most expensive team in the game. Is it Manuel’s fault?
Let’s take some of the arguments one by one…
If Omar had built a better farm system, players could have come up and taken the place of the injured like on other teams. Now let’s be fair. Would the Mets be in the same predicament if only one of the three core players were out? If it were only Delgado, then Daniel Murphy likely would be a reasonable substitute. He lacks the experience at first that Delgado has but his glove is likely better. And if he was the only offensive replacement, he might be able to relax and hit the way he did last season. The same could be said for Cora subbing for Reyes or Fernando Martinez picking up the slack for Beltran. But when all three go down, Mets fans expect the same production from these three really young players. That’s a bit unfair. Can you let me know what other organization has so many farm hands waiting in the wings to replace three super stars on the Major League level?
The Wilpons did not want to spend the money to get better offensive players in the off season like Manny Ramirez or Bobby Abreu. Well what would Mets fans have said if Manny was a Met then got suspended for 50 games? Abreu would have been nice but the Mets are trying to get younger and they felt Nick Evans or Daniel Murphy would become that kind of hitter. They still might. First off, any Mets fans that complain of the Wilpons being cheap are simply not doing their homework. The Mets have the highest payroll in the National League, second highest in baseball next to the Yankees. Then some say they pay out a lot of money but they don’t spend it wisely. Johan Santana wasn’t wise? K-Rod and Putz wasn’t a wise move? What about Beltran, Delgado, and Pedro Martinez a couple years back. They were bad signings? Sure, there is always a clunker or two but even criticizing the Perez signing is premature.
Minaya should be fired if he doesn’t make a deal. Who is he going to acquire? Mets fans think that major league general managers just sit around waiting for the Mets to call. It’s as if their one goal is to help the Mets get better. No GM is going to give the Mets their star players. First off, teams have to match up. Secondly they must get equal talent in return.
There is one area where Mets fans have a legitimate complaint and that’s the defense. The Mets have been simply terrible this year in the field and on the base paths. Manuel and his coaching staff must be held accountable for that. But realistically, as bad as the Mets have been defensively and running bases, had the injuries not occurred, they would likely be in contention regardless.
The way I see it, Minaya is making the right decision. Stay the course and hope Beltran, Delgado, and Reyes get back before its too late. The other option is to over pay with prospects for marginal players at best who may not make any difference. And knowing Mets fans, when some of those prospects flourish in other organizations, they will scream to high heaven of what a short sighted decision it was to trade them.
Mets fans, its tough luck this year. These are not the Mets of Art Howe or Jeff Torborg. There are better days ahead. Unfortunately, we will have to wait for them a bit longer.
